The office-centric model most are using just doesn’t work
The one question we’ve been asked most frequently recently is ‘Is Hybrid Work Worth It?’. We think it’s a definite yes but not the way that most enterprises are planning to implement it. From what we’re seeing, the most likely outcome is going look a lot like the hybrid work models that existed before the pandemic. Staff come into work two or three days per week and either self-organise or agree their working arrangements with their manager.
It’s an office-centric model where the office is your base but you can work at home two or three days a week because you seem to like it while your employer saves a packet on office rent. We think that this is about as inefficient a work model as you could come up with. While some employees may like it, it’s going to be less effective and less efficient than working fully remote and make it harder for managers to manage. It promises to make work more chaotic, be costly and time consuming to set up and maintain without returning much benefit. Implemented this way, is hybrid work worth it? We don’t think so!
Our recommendation is that companies work with a Remote Work and Meet Up model which delivers all of the benefits of remote work and more, while removing well-established issues with loneliness, teamwork and isolation.
There are a whole lot of problems with the office-centric model:
How many desks do we need for hybrid work?
Companies are going to close offices and set up hot desking areas, so their first challenge will be to build a model that predicts how much office space will need to be retained. We’d expect companies to be cautious about this given they won’t want to be renting new offices immediately after closing existing ones. They’ll also have to build growth plans into these calculations. So savings from closing offices are likely slow to realise and given office costs are the second highest expense for most businesses, this isn’t good.
So I travelled into the office but there were no desks available when I got there!
Staff may well arrive at work and be unable to find a desk, so to make this work you’re going to need a desk booking system, plus of course some way of policing of this given some people will book desks and no-show. The good news is that there are plenty of desk and room booking systems out there and even one or two that incorporate sensors built into desks that can detect if they really are occupied or just booked but empty. Read our review of the leading desk booking systems for hybrid work.
Forget hybrid work, I don’t ever want to work remotely!
There are going to be some who given the choice won’t ever want to work anywhere but the office. How are you going to handle this? They will in effect become higher overhead staff so are you going to allow this? Will they get a permanent desk or hot desk like everyone else? Most desk booking systems will allow you to allocate some desks as being permanently in use.
The dangers of ambition and discrimination
It’s very likely that many of the people who spend a lot of time at the office will be managers, particularly the ambitious ones and particularly those whose manager also likes to spend a lot of time at the office.
It’s always been a maxim that if you want to move your career forward then make sure you find excuses to get in front of your manager’s manager. Make sure they know your face. If they’re spending lots of time in the office then so too will be the people who are anxious to get noticed. Ask these guys ‘Is hybrid work worth it?’ and you’ll get a resounding yes…but for everyone else! This leads to a culture where all are supposedly equal but some are more equal than others.
All sorts of issues will roll out of this, not the least of which, claims that remote workers are being discriminated against. You may lose valuable staff as a result or in the worst case this could escalate into legal action. You’re going to have to manage this.
Didn’t you hear? We discussed that in the office and we’re not doing it that way anymore!
The day your manager and their manager got together in the office and decided to trash what you’re working on just happened to be one of the days you were working remotely….and they didn’t think to tell you. The first thing you hear about this is at a meeting, where you look like some sort of fool. This of course can happen just as easily with a one-to-one call over video conference but that requires a deliberate planned act as opposed to bumping into each other in the office and kicking off a discussion.
This isn’t an imaginary situation, it happened to me. There was no malice involved just a lack of communication. Two people on the ground, meeting face-to-face, made a decision that affected me but they didn’t consult or inform me. Not good management but it happens! Communication is key.
Where are you – remote, in the office or travelling?
Managers will want to know where their staff are. This can get particularly complex if you have more than one office, so an employee could be at one of the offices, working remotely or travelling between any of those places. Do you search diaries? If so, you’re going to have to impose a discipline so all staff use their diaries in a way that indicates what location they’re in. You might want to look at OfficeSync which is a simple system which indicates where people are.
Does anyone care about me?
This sort of hybrid work has an even greater propensity to leave employees feeling uncared for and out on a limb. If only I could meet with my manager – they’re never where I am and when they are, they’re too busy to see me. My views never seem to be heard! It’s even more important to have an employee engagement policy for hybrid work and use an employee engagement package. We particularly like 15Five and it works well for either fully remote or hybrid work.
How do I manage a hybrid work team?
This is a similar issue to ‘Does anyone care about me’. You can use project and task management tools to set employees tasks and manage them but these won’t help you engage with your team. Employee engagement tools are particularly strong for this and again we really like 15Five for strengthening the connection between manager and team members.
In hybrid work most meetings will still be by video conference
Inevitably if you run this sort of Hybrid then you will have people coming into work to attend meetings where some participants are in the office and others are working remotely. How are you going to organise this? If everyone does this from their desk computer then you’re going to end up with a very noisy environment and the ludicrous arrangement where you end up in a video meeting with the guy sitting in the next desk. A better idea is to set up dedicated video conference rooms where the people in the office can meet face-to-face and those calling in can be displayed on a big screen. If you’re going to do this then do it properly. Every dollar spent on video conferencing rooms is money well spent and the more you spend the better your meetings will work.
Good videoconferencing kit includes a smart camera that zooms in on the speaker – not just one that shows a wide view of the room where you can barely make out faces. It has high resolution cameras, and screens and good quality sound. Just about every software vendor will support 1080p high resolution images but the some will give you 4K resolution which provides stunning video images. When you use these facilities you feel like you’re talking to a real person and not to a grainy image of a room with some anonymous people sat in it. You really need to ask Is hybrid worth it if you don’t have this sort of video conference set up.
Employers risk legal action if they fail to maintain safe environments
The last thing you want is to invite people into the office who are infected with COVID. Employers have a duty, usually a legal requirement to provide a healthy and safe working environment for employees. Finding that large numbers of staff are either ill or having to self-isolate could threaten your business and on top of that if the worst was to happen or an employee was left permanently disabled by long COVID then employers could find themselves defending legal actions raised against them.
How healthy are your office buildings?
- Does the air conditioning recirculate air, facilitating the spread of viruses?
- Can you provide adequate ventilation?
What specific COVID measures do you need to implement?
- Do you need to test people for COVID?
- Are you going to require them to wear masks on your premises?
- Are you going to ban non-vaccinated employees from entering offices?
- Are you going to insist all new employees are double vaccinated as a condition of employment and is any of this discriminatory?
- Do you need to employ more cleaners and have a much more intensive cleaning regime, particularly where desks are shared?
- Do you need a policy to cover vulnerable and disabled people who are likely to be more at risk from infection?
This is a legal minefield and you need to consult a competent lawyer with experience in this field. The Remote Work and Meet Up model is much cleaner. You know who has been invited to the meet-up and these get togethers are planned, so you can test everyone before they arrive.
A number of desk booking systems provide help with COVID safety – desk cleaning and health questionnaires – see our review of these packages.
While you could say that the other issues are an inconvenience, health and safety issues can add significantly to your costs and really should make you ask ‘Is Hybrid work worth it’ for this sort of model.
So is hybrid work worth it. We think a definite yes, but not if you organise it this way. If you believe you can handle all of these issues then we definitely wish you good luck because you’re going to need it! You’re also going to need to invest in new facilities and tools to make it work. We think the risks, issues and costs resulting from this way of working make it impractical especially when there is a much better, tried and trusted approach available.
Gren Gale is a consultant in Remote Work and Project Management and has been named as one of the top 19 Key Opinion Leaders globally in remote work in Who’s Who in Remote Working? He is author of the Remote Project Manager and Remote Work The New Normal.
Articles and reviews on this site are written from an unbiased viewpoint. We only review products which are relevant to Remote Work or Project Management and ones we believe in. Once this article on ‘Is Hybrid Work Worth it’ was written we looked to see if some of the links could generate affiliate income. It won’t make us rich but it helps pay the rent!